How to Make Mexican Vanilla Extract (2024)

ByLola Wiarco DweckPublished onApril 14, 2015December 13, 2023Updated onDecember 13, 2023

Mexican vanilla is the edible bean born from the vanilla planifolia orchid, grown predominantly in the state of Veracruz. It has a higher vanillin content compared to other varieties and the combination of the orchid’s natural attributes, region’s climate, and traditional production and cultivation techniques result in exceptional flavor that makes Mexican vanilla beans among the best in the world.

If you’re on the market for a high quality vanilla extract, be prepared to pay a premium. Unlike store-bought vanilla extracts that oftentimes infuse artificial flavors, coloring, and additives, this extract is pure and robust in flavor. Once you make your own vanilla extract, you will realize that there is absolutely no substitute. It’s a favorite during baking season along with nutmeg and cinnamon, of course.

WHAT IS SPECIAL ABOUT MEXICAN VANILLA?

Mexican vanilla commands a premium price. Here are a few fun facts to help you understand what makes it so special (and worth every penny!):

• Hand-pollination = higher cost: Due to the decline in the Melipona bee population, most vanilla in Mexico is now hand-pollinated, making the process labor-intensive and contributing to its higher cost. It’s currently the second most expensive spice in the world after saffron.
• Unique flavor profile: Its flavor is often described as smooth and creamy with soft floral notes and a sweet marshmallow aroma, which might be why we love it in ice cream, frosting, and cupcakes!
• Vanillin content: Mexican vanilla typically has a higher vanillin content compared to other vanilla varieties. Vanillin is the primary compound responsible for the characteristic vanilla flavor, making its extract particularly potent, aromatic, and flavorful. This makes them the richest vanilla beans on the market, in my opinion!
• Regulations and authenticity: To protect the authenticity and quality of traditional Mexican vanilla, the Mexican government implemented strict regulations. Authentic Mexican vanilla must contain at least 35% alcohol by volume and be made from pure vanilla extract without the addition of artificial flavors or additives. The alcohol content also gives it an indefinite shelf life.

BRIEF HISTORY

• Ancient origins: Traditional Mexican vanilla has a rich history dating back to ancient Mesoamerica, where the Vanilla planifolia orchid grew naturally. The indigenous people of Mexico, including the Totonacs and Aztecs, were the first to cultivate and use this sacred herb in medicine and recipes, including their chocolate-based beverages. They most likely used a metate to extract the oils from whole vanilla beans to add to their chocolate caliente and atole drinks.
• Spanish conquest: The Spanish conquistadors encountered vanilla during their conquest of Mexico in the 16th century. Fascinated by its exotic aroma, they brought it back to Spain, where it quickly gained popularity as a luxurious and coveted spice.
• Veracruz, the birthplace of vainilla: Papantla, a town in the state of Veracruz, Mexico, is considered the birthplace of vanilla. Its warm climate and fertile soil provide the ideal conditions for growing the absolute best vanilla orchids, making Veracruz a leading producer of vanilla in Mexico.
• Threatened existence: Vanilla production faced a significant setback when vanilla orchids outside of Mexico lost their natural pollinator, the Melipona bee. This led to the development of hand-pollination techniques, which are now widely used to ensure the survival and cultivation of vanilla vine outside of its native environment.

For more vanilla history, check out the Hungry for History podcast episode, Vanilla: The Edible Orchid.

WHAT IS VANILLA EXTRACT?

Pure Mexican Vanilla Extract is made from premium, hand-selected beans cultivated in Mexico that are infused into 35% alcohol. Its smooth essence enhances the flavors of:

• Old-Fashioned Carrot Cake
• Paletas
• Aguas frescas
• French toast
• Oatmeal
• Mexican vanilla cupcakes
• Mexican vanilla ice cream

Note: If using pure varieties of Mexican vanilla extract, a small amount goes a long way too – one tablespoon of extract or vanilla bean paste is equivalent to one vanilla bean.

WHERE TO BUY AUTHENTIC MEXICAN VANILLA?

• Online retailers including Lola’s Mercadito (for Mexican Vanilla Extract and other vanilla products) and Voladores Vanilla
• Specialty spice shops
• Gourmet food stores

WHY IS MEXICAN VANILLA SO EXPENSIVE?

Mexican vanilla is more potent, complex, and aromatic compared to other vanilla varieties. According to Voladores Vanilla, there are several reasons why Mexican vanilla tends to be more expensive than vanilla from other countries:

• Mexican vanilla is very scarce due to farmers not being paid fair prices by large companies or middlemen. As a result, many farmers turn to other more profitable crops like corn.
• Mexican vanilla beans are still grown and cured using traditional methods unlike in other countries like Indonesia and Madagascar. This means that each vanilla pod is sun-dried on straw mats rather than baked in industrial ovens in order to achieve maximum aroma and flavor.
• Mexico is the birthplace of vanilla and in the past has benefitted from the perfect growing conditions for the plant – sunlight to shade ratio, humidity, altitude and rainfall. However, due to climate change, Mexican vanilla farmers have struggled greatly with their crops due to excess heat and rainfall damaging entire lots of vanilla pods.

Now, if all of this vanilla talk left you inspired, here’s how you can make authentic Mexican vanilla extract at home. This step-by-step guide will help you create a high-quality, aromatic extract that will step up your dessert recipes with the smooth, creamy, and flavorful essence of Mexican vanilla.

INGREDIENTS

To make Mexican vanilla extract, you will need:

• Mexican vanilla beans: Look for plump, moist beans that are oily to the touch. I buy my Mexican vanilla beans from Voladores Vanilla.
• Vodka: You will need vodka with at least 35% alcohol content. The vodka acts as the solvent to extract the flavor compounds from the vanilla beans. This is important for proper extraction and preservation of the vanilla flavor. Lower alcohol content may result in a weaker extract.

Note: The quality of the ingredients plays a significant role in the final outcome of your vanilla extract. Using high-quality Mexican vanilla beans and a neutral alcohol such as vodka will contribute to a more flavorful and aromatic extract.

RECOMMENDED FOR THIS RECIPE

MEXICAN VANILLA BEANS

For the richest and highest grade beans, I buy in bulk fromVoladores Vanilla, which sources traditional varieties directly from small growers in Papantla, Veracruz. They come vacuum sealed and are much fresher than what you’ll find in most spice shops.VIEW PRODUCT

STEP-BY-STEP INSTRUCTIONS

According to FDA standards, you need approximately 1 gram of vanilla beans per 10 mL of alcohol. So, you would need 35 grams of vanilla for a 350 mL bottle of alcohol or approximately 10-12 gourmet grade vanilla beans (or about 15 – 18 extract grade) to make approximately 12 ounces of extract. To learn more about the different types of vanilla beans, visit Voladores Vanilla.

1.GATHER INGREDIENTS AND SUPPLIES

To make your own Mexican vanilla extract, you’ll need:

• 12 gourmet grade Mexican vanilla beans
• 12 ounces of vodka (at least 35% alcohol content)
• A clean, airtight glass bottle for storage

2. COMBINE INGREDIENTS

• Start by carefully slicing the vanilla beans lengthwise, exposing the seeds inside. This step is crucial as it allows the flavor to infuse into the liquid more effectively. While slicing, ensure the beans remain intact and don’t slice all the way through to the other side. I actually like to scrape out the seeds and add them to the bottle before adding the beans.
• Place the sliced vanilla beans into the glass bottle. Pour the vodka over the beans, making sure they are fully submerged. Seal the bottle tightly.

3. INFUSE AND AGE

• Store the bottle in a cool, dark place, such as a kitchen cabinet or pantry for at least eight weeks. Note: longer infusion times will intensify the flavor. Remember to shake the bottle gently every few days to aid the infusion process.

4. ENJOY OR GIFT YOUR HOMEMADE MEXICAN VANILLA EXTRACT

• Once the aging period is complete, strain the extract to remove the vanilla bean remnants. You now have your own authentic Mexican vanilla extract!
• If desired, transfer it to a smaller, dark glass bottle with a dropper or small funnel for convenient use in your recipes. I like to add one spent vanilla bean cut in half to each bottle. You can also use the spent vanilla beans to infuse flavor into granulated sugar.

LOOKING FOR MORE INSPIRATION?

• Lavender Cookies with Vanilla
• Mango and Vanilla Yogurt Paletas
• Homemade Kumquat and Vanilla Bean Jam
• Strawberry and Vanilla Cream Paletas with Chia
• Sweet Citrus Fruits Salad with Mexican Vanilla Bean Simple Syrup
• Interview with Nicole Reyna, Founder of Voladores Vanilla and Flan and Apple Pie